Constitutionalism: Nation, Culture, and Constitutions

Information Introduction

LAW9283
Section 1, Fall 23

Schedule Information

Enrollment: 16/16
Credits: 3
Days Time Room Start Date End Date

Tue

1830-2030 SL294

Course Description

In 1989, the Berlin Wall came down. In 1991, the Soviet Union came to an end, and apartheid was abolished in South Africa. The next year, 1992, Francis Fukuyama wrote The End of History and the Last Man. In that book, Fukuyama wrote that we were witnessing, not just the end of the Cold War, but the “universalization of Western liberal democracy as the final form of human government.” During those same years, I spent time comparing notes with drafters at work on new constitutions in post-communist Central and Eastern Europe. Hopeful of their countries’ being readmitted to the family of western democracies, those drafters hewed closely to western principles of liberal constitutional democracy. Those principles included such fundamentals as free and fair elections, a free press, independent courts, and constitutional supremacy. Drafters drew heavily on international norms as reflected in such documents as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the European Convention of Human Rights, as well as important western constitutions such as Germany’s Basic Law of 1949. Today, how different things look. The widely shared optimism about the global spread of liberal constitutional democracy has been undermined by nationalism, populism, and xenophobia in many parts of the world. We reckon now with the aggressive assertion of national interests in Putin’s Russia and in China. British voters have given us Brexit, and Scottish nationalists urge a second referendum on independence. Far-right parties unsettle European politics. In Hungary, one party has a two-thirds majority in Parliament and has been dismantling many of the post-communist era guarantees, undermining the judiciary and press freedoms. In the United States, the recent presidential election reminded us of the force of populism and nationalism. This picture informs the purpose of this seminar on Constitutionalism. It will examine the extent to which constitutions and constitutionalism reflect the history, traditions, culture, and politics of a particular people. When people talk about their “nation,” what are they talking about? How do they give voice, in their constitutional arrangements, to national impulses and aspirations? Using Anglo-American constitutionalism as a point of reference, we will consider what other countries do. We will take up several case studies of specific countries, such as Turkey (from Ataturk to Erdogan) and the United Kingdom in the wake of Brexit. As a sidebar, we will consider, in the domestic American constitutional context, the nearest counterpart to the idea of nation -- the place of community values. These arise in such cases as those involving obscenity, church and state, and cruel and unusual punishment. Also worthy of attention are American state constitutions. Unlike the Federal Constitution, the state documents are periodically revised and easily amended. Thus, state constitutions and court decisions interpreting them remind us of the influence of local culture and politics on American constitutional development.

Course Requirements

Exam Information

Final Type (if any): None

Description: None

Written Work Product

Students will be required to submit a substantial research paper via EXPO no later than noon on December 18, 2023.

Other Course Details

Prerequisites: Constitutional Law useful but not required. Concurrencies: None

Exclusive With: Comparative Constitutional Law Seminar (9016), Constitutionalism: History and Jurisprudence (9019)

Laptops Allowed: Yes

First Day Attendance Required: No

Course Resources: To be announced.

Course Notes:

Graduation Requirements

Satisfies Understanding Bias/Racism/Cross-Cultural Competency requirement: No

Satisfies Writing Requirement: Yes

Credits For Prof. Skills Requirement: No

Satisfies Professional Ethics: No

Additional Course Information

Schedule No.: 123819774

Modified Type: ABA Seminar

Cross Listed: No

Concentrations: Constitutional Law , Jurisprudence and Comparative Law

Evaluation Portal Via LawWeb Opens: Tuesday, November 28, 07:01 PM

Evaluation Portal Via LawWeb Closes: Friday, December 08, 11:59 PM

Information reflected on this page was last refreshed at: Friday, September 29, 2023 - 6:12 AM *

*During open enrollment periods, live enrollment data may be found in SIS.