We explore how adding pro-social preferences to the canonical precaution model of accidents changes either the efficient damages rule or the harm from accidents. For a utilitarian lawmaker, making the potential injurer sympathetic to the victim of harm has no effect on either outcome. On the other hand, making injurers averse to harming others reduces the harm from accidents but has no effect on efficient damages. For an atomistic lawmaker—one who excludes pro-social preferences from social welfare—cultivating a taste for either harm aversion or perfect sympathy can reduce efficient damages, though neither has any effect on the amount of harm from accidents. On the other hand, causing people to act as if they are averse to harm creation, such as out of habit or moral obligation, reduces both the efficient amount of damages and total harm. In general, encouraging either a distaste for, or moral commitment against, harm creation is useful while inculcating sympathy for victims of harm is not.
Citation
Michael D. Gilbert & Andrew Hayashi, Do Good Citizens Need Good Laws? Economics and the Expressive Function, 22 Theoretical Inquiries in Law, 153 (2021).
More in This Category
Lee C. Buchheit
Lenders are perfectly free to decide for themselves whether, when, how, to whom and on what terms they will extend credit to a sovereign borrower. But...
More
This Essay is built around a central empirical claim: that most reforms and interventions in the criminal legal space are shown to have little lasting...
More
This chapter studies political corruption and its many relationships to the law of democracy. It begins with bribery laws, which forbid officials from...
More
Many countries have attempted to tap their diasporas by issuing bonds. This has particularly been the case in times of dire need (wars, pandemics...
More
June Carbone
The pathway to stable and secure middle-class status involves two elements: the ability to postpone family formation to facilitate human capital...
More
The past few years have witnessed a particular accusation leveled repeatedly and loudly at the U.S. Supreme Court’s conservative supermajority: that...
More
Michael S. Knoll
Courts and commentators have long understood dormant Commerce Clause doctrine to contain two types of cases: discrimination and undue burdens. This...
More
A key question in the academic and policy debates over the optimal architecture for sovereign debt has long been whether sovereigns should be given...
More
Lee C. Buchheit
In days of yore, sovereign borrowers needing debt relief negotiated with two groups of creditors—the bilateral (government) creditors that comprised...
More
Aurelie Ouss
Courts routinely use low cash bail as a financial incentive to ensure that released defendants appear in court and abstain from crime. This can create...
More
Over the last thirty years, almost every time I stepped out of my narrow academic path to do something that, I hoped, was for the greater public good...
More
We examine the legal terms in the market for green bonds, debt instruments in which proceeds are earmarked, directly or indirectly, for projects with...
More
Lee C. Buchheit
All sovereign debt restructurings are inherently messy, expensive, exasperating, time-consuming and contentious. These are the familiar pathologies in...
More
In 1968, the U.S. stock market collapsed. It did not flatline, of course, but major markets closed every Wednesday in an event now known as the "Wall...
More
Lee Buchheit
Things have changed since the days when debt-stricken countries only had to negotiate with government creditors in the so-called Paris Club and with...
More
Robert Cooter
This comprehensive textbook applies economic analysis to public law. The economic analysis of law has revolutionized legal scholarship and teaching in...
More
Yonathan A. Arbel
False information causes harm, threatening individuals, groups, and society. Many people struggle to judge the veracity of the information around them...
More
This book is the only text devoted to the legal problems raised by foreign investment and business transactions in emerging markets. Its organization...
More