Unpacking the Doubt in “Beyond a Reasonable Doubt”: Plausible Alternative Stories Increase Not Guilty Verdicts

Barbara A. Spellman; ;

Scholarship

Unpacking the Doubt in “Beyond a Reasonable Doubt”: Plausible Alternative Stories Increase Not Guilty Verdicts

Barbara A. Spellman

CO-AUTHORS Haley M. Cleary D. and Elizabeth R. Tenney

PUBLISHER

Basic & Applied Social Psychology

DATE

2009

UVA Law Faculty Affiliations

Barbara A. Spellman

Center for Criminal Justice

Citation

Haley M. Cleary, Barbara A. Spellman & Elizabeth R. Tenney, Unpacking the Doubt in “Beyond a Reasonable Doubt”: Plausible Alternative Stories Increase Not Guilty Verdicts, 31 Basic & Applied Social Psychology 1-8 (2009).

More in This Category

Bad Faith Prosecution
Ann Woolhandler

Michael G. Collins
In our increasingly polarized society, claims that prosecutions are politically motivated, racially motivated, or just plain arbitrary are more... MORE
The Dangerous Few: Taking Seriously Prison Abolition and Its Skeptics
Thomas Frampton
Prison abolition, in the span of just a few short years, has established a foothold in elite criminal legal discourse. But the basic question of how... MORE
Pretrial Detention and the Value of Liberty
Megan T. Stevenson
How dangerous must a person be to justify the state in locking her up for the greater good? The bail reform movement, which aspires to limit pretrial... MORE

The Biden Administration Cracks Down on Ransomware
Kristen Eichensehr
Following several significant ransomware attacks against U.S. companies last summer, the Biden administration has acted internationally and... MORE
McCleskey Accused: Justice Powell and the Moral Price of Institutional Pride
Josh Bowers
Writing for the Supreme Court in McCleskey v. Kemp, Justice Lewis F. Powell, Jr. authored a maximalist decision that transcended capital practice and... MORE
The Future of Police Reform
Rachel Harmon
The future of police reform might be best predicted by looking to the recent past, where we find countless proposals for change. But merely looking... MORE

Algorithmic Fairness, Algorithmic Discrimination
Thomas B. Nachbar
There has been an explosion of concern about use of computers to make decisions – from hiring to lending approvals to setting prison terms –... MORE
Asymmetric Subsidies and the Bail Crisis
Rich Hynes

John F. Duffy
When individuals are arrested or indicted for a crime, governments have legitimate interests in assuring that those individuals show up for future... MORE
What If Nothing Works? On Crime Licenses, Recidivism, and Quality of Life
Josh Bowers
We accept uncritically the “recidivist premium,” which is the notion that habitual offenders are particularly blameworthy and should be punished... MORE

Arrests: What Are They Good For?
Rachel Harmon
Even police critics often assume that arrests are essential to policing. This Article challenges that assumption and argues that arrests should be... MORE
Algorithmic Risk Assessment in the Hands of Humans
Megan T. Stevenson
We evaluate the impacts of adopting algorithmic risk assessments as an aid to judicial discretion in felony sentencing. We find that judges'... MORE
The Law of the Police
Rachel Harmon
The Law of the Police is the first book to explore the complex array of federal, state, and local legal rules that govern police encounters with the... MORE

The Trial Lottery
Darryl K. Brown
Juries are the lifeblood of our criminal justice system. As the Framers clearly understood, and as the Supreme Court has consistently reaffirmed in... MORE
Does Cash Bail Deter Misconduct?
Megan T. Stevenson
Courts routinely use low cash bail as a financial incentive to ensure that released defendants appear in court and abstain from crime. This can... MORE
Changing the Law to Change Policing: First Steps
Rachel Harmon
Recent events have brought to the fore longstanding concerns about the nature of policing in the United States and how it undermines racial equity.... MORE

Impact of Risk Assessment on Judges’ Fairness in Sentencing Relatively Poor Defendants
John T. Monahan
The increasing use of risk assessment algorithms in the criminal justice system has generated enormous controversy. Advocates emphasize that... MORE
Judging Risk
John T. Monahan
Risk assessment plays an increasingly pervasive role in criminal justice in the United States at all stages of the process—from policing to pretrial... MORE
In Defense of Reentry: A Response to Shreya Subramani’s Productive Separations
Thomas Frampton

Kelly Orians
Shreya Subramani’s Essay offers an incisive, critical, and sobering appraisal of the “reentry space” in New Orleans, Louisiana. She complicates our... MORE

Scholarship

Unpacking the Doubt in “Beyond a Reasonable Doubt”: Plausible Alternative Stories Increase Not Guilty Verdicts

UVA Law Faculty Affiliations

Citation

More in This Category

ABOUT

APPLY

ACADEMICS

SERVICES

PEOPLE

CAREERS

NEWS & EVENTS

COMMUNITY