Ethan Yale

Anti-Basis

PUBLISHER
North Carolina Law Review
DATE
2016
 

Abstract

Anti-basis is the untaxed benefit enjoyed by a taxpayer when a liability or obligation is incurred. In the business context, the untaxed benefit is an increase in asset basis or a tax deduction. In the personal context, the untaxed benefit might take one of those forms, or it might be (nondeductible) personal consumption. A well-functioning income tax system must keep track of any such untaxed benefit. If the liability from which the benefit derived is avoided by the taxpayer, the prior untaxed benefit must be taken into income (or must reduce basis). If there was no prior untaxed benefit relating to a liability, exceptions are necessary to various rules requiring income recognition (or basis reduction) on discharge or shifting of liabilities.

Present law requires taxpayers to account for anti-basis, but it does so ad hoc. Various sections tacitly incorporate anti-basis - such as sections 108(e)(2), 357(c)(3), and the partnership definition of “liabilities” in regulation § 1.752-1(a)(4), to take just a few of the many examples - but each section exists on an island. A few prior commentators have sensed that a common underlying concept ties these rules together. Prior to this article, however, there has been no thorough investigation of this concept. 

Citation

Ethan Yale, Anti-Basis, 94 North Carolina Law Review 485-537 (2016).
 

More in This Category