Curious about the merits of judges Donald Trump appointed in his first term as president, we previously looked at the performance of Trump-appointed judges as compared to those appointed by other presidents. On a set of three measures—productivity, influence, and independence—the Trump judges performed as well, if not better, than judges appointed by Presidents Obama and Bush. As for President Biden’s appointees, they did systemically worse than Trump’s. Biden judicial selections were, at the time we did our prior study, however, new judges. Maybe, we wondered, these judges would do better on our measures a year or two hence? What follows are our preliminary results on that question. Our short answer is that Trump judges continue to dominate the Biden judges.
Tradition is most well known today for starring in blockbuster Supreme Court cases about controversial social issues, notably abortion and firearms...
In January 2026, in a case involving transgender access to sports, a doctrinal question created confusion among both Republican and Democratic...
We examine how well citation metrics correspond to a market valuation of legal scholars in lateral hiring. We find that professors’ citation counts...
Something is amiss in empirical economics. Despite the advances of the credibility revolution, published estimates tend to be inflated and...
As Pride Month celebrations drew to a close on the last day of June, the Supreme Court delivered another blow to the LGBTQ+ movement. Earlier in its...
All she wanted was her day in court. In West Virginia v. B.P.J, Becky Pepper-Jackson sought a trial to definitively resolve what has become a burning...
In one of the last decisions in argued cases this term, West Virginia v. B.P.J., the Supreme Court held that state bans forbidding transgender girls...
Embedded in a recently decided Supreme Court case about Cuba and the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act—Exxon Mobil v. Cimex—was a debate about the...
The Supreme Court’s turn to “history and tradition” raises the critical question of what to do about “bad traditions.” If the customs of yore were...
In recent years, “tradition” has been influentially invoked in constitutional rights adjudication and legal scholarship. The Supreme Court, in...
The idea that racial prejudice contributes to discrimination not only deliberately but also in a more automatic fashion has been one of the most...
On Friday, the archconservative U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit issued a stunning nationwide injunction that directly affects one-fourth of...
In the four years since the Supreme Court decided Dobbs, cases involving abortion have come before it repeatedly. Each time, the court has ducked the...
The U.S. Supreme Court has decided that patients can continue to get mifepristone, one of the two drugs used for medication abortion, via telehealth...
In Chiles v. Salazar, the Supreme Court held that Colorado’s law prohibiting licensed counselors from seeking to change the sexual orientation or...
Curious about the merits of judges Donald Trump appointed in his first term as president, we previously looked at the performance of Trump-appointed...
After an impatient wait, the U.S. Supreme Court finally handed down its opinion in Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, the tariffs case, on Friday, Feb...
Equal protection doctrine requires that laws which treat people differently on the basis of race and sex are subject to a higher level of judicial...