Every generation of law students learns the law from a handful of judicial heroes: Cardozo, Hand, Traynor, and—for the last four decades—Posner and Easterbrook. We ask who is next in line. Cross-referencing the 155 active judges of the U.S. courts of appeals (2024-25) against fifty current casebooks spanning thirty-four subjects, we find . . . nobody. The teaching canon of the mid-2020s is dominated by the same two Reagan appointees who dominated it a quarter century ago. That is, Judges Posner and Easterbrook. Posner retired in 2017; Easterbrook turned seventy-eight this year. We document the data and ask why there are no new casebook superstars.

Citation
Stephen J. Choi & Mitu Gulati, The Last Casebook Hero, 79 Vanderbilt Law Review En Banc, 153–172 (2026).