Curious about the merits of judges Donald Trump appointed in his first term as president, two prior studies examined the performance of his appointees against those of other presidents. On a predetermined set of three measures, the Trump judges performed as well as, if not better than, judges appointed by Presidents Obama and Bush, while President Biden's appointees lagged behind. However, Biden's judicial selections were new to the bench during those initial studies. This paper is a standalone follow-up. It evaluates the 2024-2025 period to answer a lingering question: Would the Biden judges begin to close the gap as they gained seasoning? Preliminary results suggest the gap is closing in key areas, particularly in terms of writing influential opinions. When it comes to writing dissents and concurrences, however, the Trump judges lead by a wide margin.

Citation
Stephen J. Choi & Mitu Gulati, Trump v. Biden Judges – Is the Gap Closing?, ECGI Working Paper Series in Law (2027).