Roughly 1% of all petitions to be heard are taken by the Supreme Court each year; 5%, if one limits analysis to paid petitions. Getting certiorarari, in other words, is highly competitive. But little is known about the lawyers who, year in and year out, win the competition for cert. In this Essay, we unpack twenty-four years of data on petitions and the lawyers who bring them. Who are the superstars of the cert process and where do they come from?